When Jewish Day Schools Close: Navigating the Challenges and Finding New Paths

Image Source: FreeImages

## Introduction

In recent years, the Jewish day school system in northern New Jersey has faced a series of closures, leaving many students and their families grappling with the difficult task of finding alternative educational options. This article explores the impact of these closures on students, the reasons behind the shutdowns, and the strategies employed by the affected individuals to adapt to the changes. From early graduation to transitioning to public schools or other Jewish day schools, the resilience and determination of these students shine through. Let us delve into their stories and the lessons they have learned along the way. Let’s explore When Jewish Day Schools Close: Navigating the Challenges and Finding New Paths.

The Shock and Resilience of Students

For Sion Cohen, a senior at The Idea School in Tenafly, New Jersey, the news of her school’s closure just months before her final year came as a shock. Determined to graduate on time, she quickly devised a plan that involved enrolling in online classes and ensuring she had enough credits to meet the graduation requirements. Cohen’s unwavering commitment to her education is a testament to the resilience of these students when faced with unexpected challenges.

Mia Eskin, a student at Gerrard Berman Day School, also experienced the shock of discovering her school’s imminent closure. As she read the email announcement, thoughts of the cherished memories she would miss flooded her mind. From the highly anticipated eighth-grade Israel trip to the daily interactions with lifelong friends, Eskin’s emotional response highlights the deep connection students form with their schools and the sense of loss they experience when forced to leave.

The Impact of School Closures

The closures of Gerrard Berman Day School and The Idea School left more than 130 students in a state of uncertainty. These young individuals now faced the daunting task of finding new educational opportunities that aligned with their Jewish and secular needs. The sudden change took a toll on their mental health, with some students, like Charlotte Barbach, experiencing emotional breakdowns due to the loss of a familiar and beloved educational environment.

The reasons behind these closures were primarily attributed to declining enrollment and financial concerns. According to Paul Bernstein, the CEO of Prizmah, a day school resource organization, shrinking Jewish communities and the inability to sustain existing infrastructures were common causes of such closures. A national survey conducted by Prizmah in 2022 revealed that while two-thirds of Jewish day schools reported stable or growing enrollments, 34% experienced a decrease in enrollment. These statistics highlight the challenges faced by the Jewish day school system as a whole.

Navigating the Transition

With their schools no longer operating, students had to make difficult decisions about where to continue their education. Some, like Charlotte Barbach, chose to enroll in public schools, embracing the opportunity for a fresh start. While the transition was initially challenging, Barbach eventually found a sense of belonging and community in her new school, demonstrating the resilience and adaptability of these students when faced with unexpected changes.

Other students, such as Leo Milch, found solace and new opportunities in enrolling at Golda Och Academy, a school that welcomed former students from both Gerrard Berman Day School and The Idea School. The larger size of the academy provided Milch with the chance to learn from a diverse group of peers, expanding their horizons and exposing them to new ideas and perspectives.

Unique Challenges for Idea School Students

Students from The Idea School faced unique challenges during the transition due to the school’s collaborative model and small class sizes. Yahkir Scholsberg, a junior at Golda Och Academy, expressed a fondness for The Idea School’s emphasis on open conversations, where doubts and struggles could be freely discussed. While their new school also facilitated similar discussions, the frequency and openness of dialogue at The Idea School were unparalleled.

Scholsberg also noted the difference in curriculum and personalized learning at Golda Och Academy. With larger class sizes, the level of customization and focus on individual passions that The Idea School provided became less feasible. However, Scholsberg acknowledged that college would likely offer them the opportunity to delve deeply into their specific interests and subjects.

Finding New Homes and Perspectives

Despite the challenges, many students found silver linings in their new educational environments. Leo Milch, who joined Golda Och Academy shortly after The Idea School closed, appreciated the larger student body and the diverse perspectives it brought. Exposure to different ideas and ways of thinking broadened their horizons and contributed to personal growth.

Sion Cohen, who graduated early after The Idea School’s closure, embarked on a different path by attending Kean University. Though not the original plan, Cohen recognized the value of education itself, prioritizing a quality education over the prestige or reputation of a university. This shift in perspective highlights the importance of adaptability and the ability to find value in unexpected circumstances.

The Community Impact

The closure of a Jewish day school reaches far beyond the affected students. The entire community ecosystem feels the reverberations of such an event. Paul Bernstein, CEO of Prizmah, emphasized the integral role day schools play in Jewish communities. When a school shuts down, the community as a whole experiences the effects, underscoring the need to support and sustain these educational institutions.

Seeking Alternative Educational Paths

In the wake of their school closures, many students sought new educational opportunities in nearby Jewish day schools or public schools. Golda Och Academy became a haven for some, welcoming former students from both Gerrard Berman Day School and The Idea School. Other students found homes in institutions like The Frisch School, Solomon Schecter of New Milford, Yeshivat Noam, or even their local public schools. The determination and resilience of these students to continue their Jewish and secular education are truly commendable.

Lessons Learned and Moving Forward

The challenges faced by these students have taught them valuable life lessons. Eliana Nahomove, a ninth-grader at The Frisch School, acknowledged the importance of moving forward and embracing new beginnings. She emphasized the need to let go of the past and focus on the future, a sentiment echoed by many of her peers.

The experiences of these students serve as a reminder of the strength and resilience of young individuals when faced with unexpected obstacles. While the closures of their beloved schools brought about significant changes, these students have shown an unwavering commitment to their education and an ability to adapt to new environments.


The closures of Jewish day schools in northern New Jersey have undoubtedly posed significant challenges for students and their families. However, these challenges have also fostered resilience, adaptability, and newfound opportunities for growth. As these students navigate their new educational paths, they serve as a testament to the importance of community support and the indomitable spirit of youth. Their stories inspire us to embrace change, find value in unexpected circumstances, and forge ahead on our educational journeys.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *